Videos Login Subscribe Renew E-edition
logo
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
  • News
  • Features
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Letters
  • Obituaries
  • Classifieds
    • Place a Classified
  • Advertise
  • Contact us
  • Legal Notices
    • Read Statewide Legal Notices
  • Archives
    • News
    • Features
    • Opinion
      • Columns
      • Letters
    • Obituaries
    • Classifieds
      • Place a Classified
    • Advertise
    • Contact us
    • Legal Notices
      • Read Statewide Legal Notices
    • Archives
High court overrules county judge
Photo by Africa Studio/AdobeStock
Main, News
By Erin McIntyre erin@ouraynews.com on October 2, 2024
High court overrules county judge
Evidence can be used in alleged sex assault case involving ex-police chief's home

The Colorado Supreme Court has overturned a county court judge’s decision to punish the district attorney’s office for not following evidence rules and prohibit evidence not provided to the defense by deadline from being used for a preliminary hearing in a sexual assault case.

In a 5-2 decision handed down Monday, the state Supreme Court justices ruled County Court Judge Sean Murphy abused his discretion and didn’t adequately support his decision to prevent the prosecution from including evidence in the preliminary hearing for Ashton Whittington.

The ruling removes the pause that has been in place for the case since late March, when Whittington was supposed to have that preliminary hearing.

Whittington is accused of giving a 17-year-old girl alcohol at his own 18th birthday party.

The woman told law enforcement she was sexually assaulted by two others at this party at the former Ouray police chief’s home in 2023.

The decision to overturn the county court judge’s decision is significant not only in Whittington’s case, but also for the cases of his co-defendants, Gabriel Trujillo and Nathan Dieffenderffer, the former police chief’s stepson.

Whittington has been charged with a class 2 misdemeanor for allegedly providing alcohol to the underage woman, a class 4 felony for contributing to the delinquency of a minor and a class 3 felony sexual assault. At this point the prosecution has not produced any evidence suggesting Whittington actually sexually assaulted the woman, but his arrest affidavit indicates he was present when she said the others committed the crime.

The state Supreme Court’s ruling means the prosecution can use all the evidence it has disclosed to the defense in an upcoming preliminary hearing, which requires the prosecution to show the court it has enough evidence to move forward with a trial.

The state has rules governing how evidence should be disclosed in court – the Colorado Rules of Criminal Procedure. The rule in question here is referred to as “rule 16,” requiring the district attorney’s office to hand over evidence to the defense it planned to use within 21 days of filing charges against Whittington. In this case, that means everything should have been provided to the public defender’s office by Jan. 17.

While the prosecution gave some evidence to the defense on Dec. 27, 2023, shortly after Whittington’s arrest, it did not hand over the rest within the 21-day window required by the state rules.

Instead, there were four more sets of evidence handed over in February and March. The justices noted in their decision that some of that evidence was in the hands of the prosecution during the 21-day disclosure window and it was not handed over. The high court also noted some of the evidence had errors prohibiting access, including broken links.

The dispute over the evidence escalated in February, when Whittington’s attorneys asked for evidence including a Snapchat video recovered from his phone, which the prosecution claimed supported the charges in his case, according to court records. Whittington’s attorneys also asked for body-worn camera footage of the search of the former police chief’s home, the alleged crime scene.

Whittington’s attorneys asked for this evidence again after his preliminary hearing was postponed until March.

About 90 minutes before the rescheduled preliminary hearing was set to begin on March 13, the prosecution handed over 11 videos, including the requested bodycam footage and a video interview with one of the codefendants, according to court records. Then seven more videos were provided to the defense.

At this point, when the prosecution provided this fifth set of evidence long after the 21-day deadline had passed, Chief Public Defender Patrick Crane filed a motion to dismiss Whittington’s case or impose sanctions on the district attorney’s office, citing concerns about a pattern of behavior with the district attorney’s office breaking evidence disclosure rules. In his motion, he specifically referenced 37 prior discovery violations committed by the district attorney’s office.

Though Murphy said he didn’t think the late or missing evidence was a result of any bad intent, he imposed a sanction on the prosecution, ruling that any evidence that wasn’t provided in the original 21-day window couldn’t be used in the preliminary hearing.

The hearing continued with one witness called to the stand, and then Murphy postponed the rest of the hearing.

The district attorney appealed Murphy’s decision two days after he made the ruling.

The justices did not hear oral arguments in the case and issued the ruling Monday without warning. In their written ruling, they ruled Murphy’s decision conflicted with a trial court’s duty to avoid using sanctions that exclude evidence from cases, calling it a “drastic remedy that may affect the outcome of the trial, provide a windfall to the party against whom the evidence would have been offered, or otherwise hinder the search for the truth.”

It cited concerns that excluding evidence “may tend to cut against the primary purpose of the discovery rules – to reveal the truth.”

The justices also said Murphy himself did not establish there was a pattern of discovery violations in the district attorney’s office, despite Crane’s allegations.

Flood damage fixed in a rush
Main
Flood damage fixed in a rush
In fire's wake, workers complete $2.8M emergency project
By James Hanlon 
November 18, 2026
In just over two months, an emergency public works project erected more than 2,000 feet of concrete flood barrier walls before another storm could torrent more debris flows down the Gold Mountain Fire...
this is a test
Main, News...
Electricity rate hikes approved
SMPA OKs 27% increase to access fee; fifth straight year bills will jump
By Chart Riggall 
November 18, 2026
San Miguel Power Association’s board voted unanimously Tuesday to hike nearly all of its rate categories for the next year, including a 27% increase to the flat access fee levied on the vast majority ...
this is a test
Main
In Ouray, the fireworks show will go on
By Mike Wiggins mike@ouraynews.com 
November 18, 2026
Despite fire danger concerns, council favors traditional July 4 pyrotechnics over drone display The familiar sights and sounds of Ouray’s Fourth of July fireworks display will return in 2027 — assumin...
this is a test
News
County signs off on artificial intelligence policy
Guidelines restrict employee use of AI, require training
By Gabrielle Porter, James Hanlon 
November 18, 2026
Ouray County employees will have new guardrails for how to use artificial intelligence tools in their work starting in January, after county commissioners on Tuesday approved their first-ever AI polic...
this is a test
News
Changes looming for city’s remote attendance policy
Ouray councilors reject mayor's resolution requiring in-person governance, but say current rules need tightening, enforcement
By Mike Wiggins mike@ouraynews.com 
November 18, 2026
Ouray City Council members will continue to be able to attend a limited number of meetings online each year, although councilors appear ready to tighten the rules dictating remote governance. The coun...
this is a test
News
Poisonings contradict Top of the Pines’ mission
By Dan Chancellor 
November 18, 2026
Dear Editor: When the land for Top of the Pines was donated by the Girl Scouts of America in 2002, it was specified that the wildlife must be protected in the future. The TOP mission statement provide...
this is a test
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
Editor Picks
News
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
County budget decisions reinforce skepticism
By Charles Carson 
November 18, 2026
Dear Editor: As nearly 30-year residents of Log Hill Village, we are deeply concerned by the Ouray County Board of County Commissioners' unilateral decision to appropriate the $223,000 remaining in th...
this is a test
News
CORRECTION
November 18, 2026
An article in the Nov. 12-18 edition of the Plaindealer about the elimination of Ouray County's austerity policy incorrectly indicated Road and Bridge Supervisor Ty Barger declined to comment on his r...
this is a test
Looking Back
News
Looking Back
By Compiled from the files of The Ouray County Herald, The Ridgway Sun, and The Ouray County Plaindealer 
November 18, 2026
Compiled from the files of The Ouray County Herald, The Ridgway Sun, and The Ouray County Plaindealer 60 Years Ago November 17, 1966 Five Denver youths were sentenced last Thursday in Delta after plea...
this is a test
Long before Mears, pathfinders had four legs
Columns, Feature...
Long before Mears, pathfinders had four legs
By Carolyn Snowbarger 
November 18, 2026
Visitors to Ouray often look up at the towering peaks and wonder how early miners ever reached their high-altitude claims. We rightfully memorialize Otto Mears, dubbed the "Pathfinder of the San Juan ...
this is a test
Ouray tops rival, prepares to host tournament
News
Ouray tops rival, prepares to host tournament
November 18, 2026
this is a test
Facebook

Remote-triggered avalanche in San Juan Mountains

First responders receive first COVID-19 vaccines

Ouray County Plaindealer
Office address:

195 S Lena St. Unit D
Ridgway, Colorado 81432
970-325-4412

Mailing address:
PO Box 529
Ridgway CO 81432

This site complies with ADA requirements

© 2023 Ouray County Plaindealer

  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Accessibility Policy