Videos Login Subscribe Renew E-edition
logo
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
  • News
  • Features
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Letters
  • Obituaries
  • Classifieds
    • Place a Classified
  • Advertise
  • Contact us
  • Legal Notices
    • Read Statewide Legal Notices
  • Archives
    • News
    • Features
    • Opinion
      • Columns
      • Letters
    • Obituaries
    • Classifieds
      • Place a Classified
    • Advertise
    • Contact us
    • Legal Notices
      • Read Statewide Legal Notices
    • Archives
County: Forest Service violated federal law
U.S. Sen. Michael Bennet, center, visits with, left to right, Ouray County Commissioner Lynn Padgett, Ouray Mayor Ethan Funk, then-interim City Administrator Joe Coleman and Ouray District Ranger Dana Gardunio during a visit to Crystal Reservoir in October 2025. Erin McIntyre — Ouray County Plaindealer
News
By Lia Salvatierra lia@ouraynews.com on March 26, 2025
County: Forest Service violated federal law
Letter alleges agency failed to follow proper procedures before Crystal Reservoir drawdown

Ouray County leaders sent a letter to the U.S. Forest Service arguing the agency violated the National Environmental Policy Act when it partially drained Crystal Reservoir and proposed permanently removing it last year.

NEPA is a federal law requiring federal agencies to consider the environmental impacts of their actions before making decisions.

The letter claims the Forest Service failed to follow proper NEPA procedures before partially draining the reservoir last summer. It says the agency did not complete a NEPA analysis or the alternative steps required under the law to complete an “emergency” drawdown. The agency said it completed a drawdown because of liability concerns about a crack identified in the reservoir’s dam during an inspection in May 2023, which has not been identified since. The move came after years of offering the city of Ouray — which claims it has water storage rights in the reservoir — options to own the reservoir and its dam. Those offers went unanswered by city officials, according to prior reporting in the Plaindealer.

But the temporary drawdown and a proposed permanent removal of the beloved recreational and aesthetic resource was a surprise, according to city and county officials who objected to the decision. After the drawdown, the city decided to seek ownership of the reservoir, dam and its associated water rights via a no-cost federal conveyance, a request made to U.S. Sen. Michael Bennet in October.

County leaders endorsed the city’s request in its letter and accused the agency of violating federal law.

The letter prepared by Ouray County Attorney Leo Caselli and Deputy County Attorney Marita Robinson comes after the county commissioned an independent review of a study the agency used to support the dam drawdown. That review found multiple flaws with the study used to classify the dam as a “high-hazard.”

The Forest Service said it was removing high-hazard, non-hydropower dams, wanting to offload the liability. The agency said it planned to start an environmental analysis for Crystal Reservoir and its dam, considering three options: removing it, restoring it or transferring ownership. It set a goal of implementing changes by 2027.

The county originally hired Lytle Water Solutions LLC in August to prepare for objections to the Forest Service’s retroactive NEPA analysis. But the agency has not begun that analysis and is also waiting on two separate dam studies to inform its decision.

Instead, the letter signed by county commissioners uses more than 20 Forest Service documents alongside the Lytle Water Solutions LLC review to argue the agency already violated NEPA when it partially drained the reservoir last summer and proposed the option to permanently remove it. The letter also says the county is prepared to issue formal objections to any future NEPA analysis results.

The letter cites case law saying a NEPA analysis must be “prepared early enough that it can serve practically as an important contribution to the decisionmaking process and will not be used to rationalize or justify decisions already being made.”

The letter argues the Forest Service repeatedly violated NEPA by making “predetermined” plans to fully remove the dam and reservoir without an environmental analysis or environmental impact statement.

It calls the NEPA violations “incurable,” if the Forest Service “rubber stamps” any predetermined decision to permanently remove the dam and reservoir.

“By all appearances, the Forest Service had a duty to follow a NEPA process to determine what the potential alternatives and impacts were,” said Commissioner Lynn Padgett during Tuesday’s commissioners’ meeting.

The Forest Service did not reply to a request for comment by deadline.

Flood damage fixed in a rush
Main
Flood damage fixed in a rush
In fire's wake, workers complete $2.8M emergency project
By James Hanlon 
November 18, 2026
In just over two months, an emergency public works project erected more than 2,000 feet of concrete flood barrier walls before another storm could torrent more debris flows down the Gold Mountain Fire...
this is a test
Main, News...
Electricity rate hikes approved
SMPA OKs 27% increase to access fee; fifth straight y ear bills will jump
By Chart Riggall 
November 18, 2026
San Miguel Power Association’s board voted unanimously Tuesday to hike nearly all of its rate categories for the next year, including a 27% increase to the flat access fee levied on the vast majority ...
this is a test
Main
In Ouray, the fireworks show will go on
By Mike Wiggins mike@ouraynews.com 
November 18, 2026
Despite fire danger concerns, council favors traditional July 4 pyrotechnics over drone display The familiar sights and sounds of Ouray’s Fourth of July fireworks display will return in 2027 — assumin...
this is a test
News
County signs off on artificial intelligence policy
Guidelines restrict employee use of AI, require training
By James Hanlon, Gabrielle Porter 
November 18, 2026
Ouray County employees will have new guardrails for how to use artificial intelligence tools in their work starting in January, after county commissioners on Tuesday approved their first-ever AI polic...
this is a test
News
Changes looming for city’s remote attendance policy
Ouray councilors reject mayor's resolution requiring in-person governance, but say current rules need tightening, enforcement
By Mike Wiggins mike@ouraynews.com 
November 18, 2026
Ouray City Council members will continue to be able to attend a limited number of meetings online each year, although councilors appear ready to tighten the rules dictating remote governance. The coun...
this is a test
News
Poisonings contradict Top of the Pines’ mission
By Dan Chancellor 
November 18, 2026
Dear Editor: When the land for Top of the Pines was donated by the Girl Scouts of America in 2002, it was specified that the wildlife must be protected in the future. The TOP mission statement provide...
this is a test
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
Editor Picks
News
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
County budget decisions reinforce skepticism
By Charles Carson 
November 18, 2026
Dear Editor: As nearly 30-year residents of Log Hill Village, we are deeply concerned by the Ouray County Board of County Commissioners' unilateral decision to appropriate the $223,000 remaining in th...
this is a test
News
CORRECTION
November 18, 2026
An article in the Nov. 12-18 edition of the Plaindealer about the elimination of Ouray County's austerity policy incorrectly indicated Road and Bridge Supervisor Ty Barger declined to comment on his r...
this is a test
Looking Back
News
Looking Back
By Compiled from the files of The Ouray County Herald, The Ridgway Sun, and The Ouray County Plaindealer 
November 18, 2026
Compiled from the files of The Ouray County Herald, The Ridgway Sun, and The Ouray County Plaindealer 60 Years Ago November 17, 1966 Five Denver youths were sentenced last Thursday in Delta after plea...
this is a test
Long before Mears, pathfinders had four legs
Columns, Feature...
Long before Mears, pathfinders had four legs
By Carolyn Snowbarger 
November 18, 2026
Visitors to Ouray often look up at the towering peaks and wonder how early miners ever reached their high-altitude claims. We rightfully memorialize Otto Mears, dubbed the "Pathfinder of the San Juan ...
this is a test
Ouray tops rival, prepares to host tournament
News
Ouray tops rival, prepares to host tournament
November 18, 2026
this is a test
Facebook

Remote-triggered avalanche in San Juan Mountains

First responders receive first COVID-19 vaccines

Ouray County Plaindealer
Office address:

195 S Lena St. Unit D
Ridgway, Colorado 81432
970-325-4412

Mailing address:
PO Box 529
Ridgway CO 81432

This site complies with ADA requirements

© 2023 Ouray County Plaindealer

  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Accessibility Policy