Videos Login Subscribe Renew E-edition
logo
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
  • News
  • Features
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Letters
  • Obituaries
  • Classifieds
    • Place a Classified
  • Advertise
  • Contact us
  • Legal Notices
    • Read Statewide Legal Notices
  • Archives
    • News
    • Features
    • Opinion
      • Columns
      • Letters
    • Obituaries
    • Classifieds
      • Place a Classified
    • Advertise
    • Contact us
    • Legal Notices
      • Read Statewide Legal Notices
    • Archives
FULFILLING PAT’S DREAM
Marti O'Leary poses in front of the Old Firehouse project in Ridgway, a mixed-use development she brought to fruition after her husband, Pat, died in March. Erin McIntyre — Ouray County Plaindealer
Feature, Main
By Mike Wiggins mike@ouraynews.com on August 28, 2024
FULFILLING PAT’S DREAM
The Old Firehouse aims to realize philanthropist Pat O’Leary’s vision of a gathering space that preserves history and boosts the economy

Pat O’Leary isn’t here. But his spirit, his fingerprints, are everywhere at the corner of North Lena and Clinton streets in Ridgway.

The grand piano in the community event space that he learned to play when he was 50. The greenhouse perched atop the remodeled 142-year-old firehouse, fashioned after one he saw in Denver. The outdoor patio that will forever bear his name, where he would have soaked up the summer evenings. The gleaming marble bar, where it’s easy to envision the Irishman from Chicago sipping his favorite drink and shaking hands with customers.

This is the space the businessman and philanthropist began imagining several years ago — a mixed-use development now known to locals as the Old Firehouse that incorporates a restaurant, an office, outdoor and indoor community spaces and residences. Pat was keen on giving new life and new purpose to this historic stone structure. Over the decades, it served as everything from a town hall, fire station and school, to an artist studio, to one of the settings for the original 1969 “True Grit” film.

It was Pat who laid the groundwork for this place, securing the necessary town permits and finances and assembled the contractors, greenhouse manager and other staff needed to build and run the operation. But Pat died of pancreatic cancer in March at the age of 71 before he could fulfill his vision, leaving it to his wife, Marti, to push the project across the finish line with the help of friends and employees.

Patron saint candles featuring images of Pat and Marti O’Leary sit inside The Hearth restaurant within the remodeled Old Firehouse building. The O’Learys purchased the old historic stone structure at the corners of Sherman and North Lena streets in 2017, intent on preserving its heritage while redeveloping the site into a community gathering place. Erin McIntyre – Ouray County Plaindealer

 

The grand opening for the restaurant and bar that serve as the centerpiece of the firehouse is planned for late September — the same month as what would have been the O’Learys’ 42nd wedding anniversary.

“It’ll be our dream that happened, and he’s not here to celebrate it,” Marti said, holding back tears as employees bustled around the restaurant. “But I wouldn’t not do it.”

***

In the Old Firehouse, the O’Learys created more than 16,000 square feet of space that simultaneously preserves Ridgway’s heritage, aims to give a shot in the arm to the local economy and reshapes the face of one of the most recognizable corners in town.

The original firehouse was built in 1882 as a home for railroad workers, nine years before the town incorporated. In the ensuing decades it served several purposes: town hall, fire station, school and social hub. The company that filmed “True Grit” built the bell tower that caps the historic red structure to make it appear more like a late 1800s school.

The building came under private ownership in the 1980s and became an art studio in the 1990s and 2000s. The owner at the time, Michael McCullough, fashioned several sculptures, while his partner, Lucy Boody, converted the vacant areas around the building into an ever-evolving garden of trees, shrubs, plants, hand-sculpted fairies and benches.

The Ridgway Firehouse is pictured here in 2015, when it was a studio for sculptors Michael McCullough and Lucy Boody. The building originated as a residence for railroad workers. Its belfry was added by the producers of the 1969 movie “True Grit.” Photo courtesy Carol M. Highsmith, Gates Frontiers Fund Colorado Collection/Library of Congress

 

The O’Learys turned their attention to the old stone structure after McCullough died in 2016. Pat, a history major at DePaul University, loathed the idea of an out-of-stater buying the building and knocking it down. So he and Marti purchased it in 2017, the starting point of a new chapter for the firehouse.

***

The Hearth is at the center of the building, offering an upscale dining experience for dinner and Sunday brunch. The sample menu features an array of unique items, from smoked trout rillette for a starter, to lemon ricotta tortellini for dinner, to Norwegian eggs benedict – with dry-cured salmon – for brunch.

“The food has to match the space,” said Daniel Castillo, whom the O’Learys brought over from the posh Elk Mountain Resort to be the executive chef at The Hearth.

The restaurant, which seats around 60 inside and 16 outside on the front patio, includes a full bar, a custom-built, gas-assisted, wood-fired pizza oven imported from Italy and a wood-fired grill.

Customers who look up when they enter the restaurant will get a peek at the origins of their meal. Windows provide a view into the 1,400-square-foot greenhouse.

The Harvest greenhouse manager Sam Nafziger walks through the 1,400-square-foot space atop the Old Firehouse building. Nafziger is in charge of growing and harvesting vegetables and herbs from the aeroponics growing system, which features 44 vertical towers that are each able to grow 40 plants. Erin McIntyre – Ouray County Plaindealer

Named The Harvest, it’s headlined by an aeroponics system featuring 44 towers that are each able to grow 40 plants. Rather than using soil, the system suspends roots in the air and irrigates them with a nutrient-rich mist. Greenhouse manager Sam Nafziger tends a variety of vegetables and herbs that will be incorporated into dishes served at The Hearth and at private gatherings at the adjoining event space.

There’s also a fruiting chamber attached to the greenhouse, where Nafziger has already harvested hundreds of pounds of mushrooms. Those are already being dried for the restaurant’s creations.

 

Nafziger holds mature oyster mushrooms ready to harvest for the restaurant. Erin McIntyre – Ouray County Plaindealer

 

Immediately to the south of the restaurant, the event space offers indoor and outdoor seating for close to 150 people, designed for weddings, retreats and other private functions.

 

This vantage point of the project shows the southeast side of the patio outside the event center, with the greenhouse visible on top of the old firehouse with the bell tower. Erin McIntyre – Ouray County Plaindealer

 

Outside the event space, Lucy’s Garden offers private patio seating and a nod to Boody’s artistic contributions to the space.

On the north side of the firehouse, a covered patio known as Pat’s Place will be a three-season hangout with pub food and drink service from a restaurant window. Diners can look forward to a rotating selection of soft-serve ice cream.

The O’Learys and their team of designers and builders did their best to retain and repurpose as many elements from the historic stone structure as possible. The restaurant sits within the three reinforced stone walls. The metal fence that surrounded the old firehouse remains. The bell tower was removed, refurbished and returned to its rightful place last year. A new bell will be rung for the first time during Pat’s memorial on Sept. 12.

Above and behind the restaurant, a 1,600-square-foot office space is ready to be rented. Behind that, four one-bedroom workforce apartments will be made available first to employees in the building, then to other local workers who qualify financially.

The third floor features two condominiums, one for O’Leary and the other for Steve Chevalier, whom the O’Learys traded the condo for a vacant lot he owned on the north corner of the building site.

***

It has been a long, arduous process for Marti to get to this point, made more challenging by the loss of her husband in the spring. She went ahead with the plan to sell their home on Log Hill, and moved into an apartment upstairs from the restaurant while their condo is being finished in the building.

While she and Pat tackled the project hand-in-hand, the vision for it really belonged to Pat. And at 75, Marti isn’t interested in overseeing an event center, restaurant and bar on her own. She’s listed the property for sale for $8.5 million, hoping a buyer will give it the same love and dedication poured into its creation.

Marti O’Leary poses in front of the Old Firehouse project in Ridgway, a mixed-use development she brought to fruition after her husband, Pat, died in March. Erin McIntyre — Ouray County Plaindealer

 

But none of that has diminished her enthusiasm for the grand opening, her attention to detail to make sure everything is in place, or the emotions that well inside her when she considers the aspects of the Old Firehouse Pat would have appreciated the most.

“I want people to enjoy everything that’s here,” Marti said.

The Old Firehouse is located at 185 N. Lena St. Dinner will be available nightly from 5-10 p.m. and brunch will be available on the weekends from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. To make reservations, call 970626-8801, and for more information, visit theoldfirehouse.com.

Ridgway girls run down state title
Main, News...
Ridgway girls run down state title
Young team blows past competition to hoist Class 2A cross country trophy
By By Matt Meyer Special to the Plaindealer 
November 5, 2025
There isn’t a perfect translation for “hill” in Chinese. That's something Natasha Hessler discovered when she arrived at the famous creek crossing during the Colorado State Cross Country Championship ...
this is a test
Underwood elected mayor
Main, News...
ELECTION 2025
Underwood elected mayor
Hart joins council, which needs to fill two spots
By Mike Wiggins mike@ouraynews.com 
November 5, 2025
Ouray City Councilor Michael Underwood won election to the mayor’s seat Tuesday night, succeeding on a campaign that emphasized fiscal conservatism and a vow to fix what he perceives as a disconnect b...
this is a test
News
Property tax hikes pass for cemetery, fire districts
By Lia Salvatierra lia@ouraynews.com 
November 5, 2025
Voters Tuesday night approved tax increases for the Cedar Hill Cemetery District and the Ouray Fire Protection District. A measure to increase the cemetery district’s mill levy from 0.33 mills to 1 mi...
this is a test
News
ELECTION 2025
Voters approve new county lodging tax
By Lia Salvatierra lia@ouraynews.com 
November 5, 2025
Voters in unincorporated Ouray County approved a new 6% lodging tax that is expected to provide more than $182,000 in additional funding during a tight 2026 budget year and into the future. The measur...
this is a test
News
ELECTION 2025
Fagrelius, Meruelo win school board seats
By Erin McIntyre erin@ouraynews.com 
November 5, 2025
Ouray voters have chosen two former educators to join the Ouray School Board, according to unofficial results from Tuesday’s election. Three candidates competed for two open seats on the school board,...
this is a test
News
Hurd introduces reservoir legislation
By Lia Salvatierra lia@ouraynews.com 
November 5, 2025
U.S. Rep. Jeff Hurd has introduced legislation to transfer ownership of Crystal Reservoir from the U.S. Forest Service to the city of Ouray, identical to a Senate bill introduced in September, after w...
this is a test
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
Editor Picks
Letters, Opinion...
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
County makes right call on prairie dogs
November 5, 2025
Dear Editor: I would like to offer a different perspective in support of the decision by the Ouray County Board of County Commissioners to proceed with management of the prairie dog colony at Top of t...
this is a test
Letters, Opinion...
LETTER TO THE EDITOR
A humble request for less puzzle pain
November 5, 2025
Dear Editor: Is it just me, or is the Plaindealer crossword puzzle often taking pleasure by inflicting pain on others (sadistic)? For example, here are some actual clues (and answers) from the Oct. 9 ...
this is a test
Letters, Opinion...
Citizens have benefited from Weiser’s record
November 5, 2025
Dear Editor: Attorney General Phil Weiser is running for governor of Colorado. As attorney general he has a proven record that has been advantageous to the citizens of Colorado. Recently President Don...
this is a test
As daylight dwindles, how can we curb energy use?
Columns, Opinion...
As daylight dwindles, how can we curb energy use?
By Karen Risch 
November 5, 2025
Ouray’s first frost occurred Oct. 17, three weeks after the average frost date, Sept. 26. It was a fitting end to a hot, droughty summer. Occasional downpours helped but were no substitute for a full ...
this is a test
News
Ouray utility bills to rise by 6%
Acting on public input, council ditches plan for new signs at Rotary Park, Hot Springs Pool entrance
By Mike Wiggins mike@ouraynews.com 
November 5, 2025
Ouray residents and business owners will see their utility bills rise by 6% next year, as the city seeks additional revenue to meet the requirements of the loans on its new wastewater and water treatm...
this is a test
Facebook

Remote-triggered avalanche in San Juan Mountains

First responders receive first COVID-19 vaccines

Ouray County Plaindealer
Office address:

195 S Lena St. Unit D
Ridgway, Colorado 81432
970-325-4412

Mailing address:
PO Box 529
Ridgway CO 81432

This site complies with ADA requirements

© 2023 Ouray County Plaindealer

  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Accessibility Policy